Showing posts with label Countries. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Countries. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 24, 2019

Hsieh Forbes Column: Health Care Vs. Liberty In Singapore

My latest Forbes column is now out: "Health Care Vs. Liberty In Singapore".

I discuss the trade-offs that Singapore residents must make when they accept government-run "universal health care" and "cost control". This is includes significant losses in liberty as well as accepting government rationing of medical services.

For more details, see the full text of "Health Care Vs. Liberty In Singapore".


Thursday, March 31, 2016

Hsieh Forbes Column on The Great Canadian Sperm Crisis

My latest Forbes piece is now up: "The Market Solution To The Great Canadian Sperm Crisis".

A couple of facts:

* There is an enormous shortage of donated sperm in Canada, such that infertile couples have to rely on (gasp) imported sperm from the US.

* The Canadian government outlaws paying Canadian sperm donors for their product.

Hmm....  Could there possibly be any connection between these two facts?

For more details, read the full text of "The Market Solution To The Great Canadian Sperm Crisis".


Wednesday, September 30, 2015

Doctors Leaving The UK

The Economist discusses the growing problem of unhappy UK physicians, "Some junior doctors consider a strike, while others pack their bags".

One possible "canary in the coal mine" indicator:
Like workers in any public service, doctors always say that morale has never been lower. But this time many are threatening to vote with their feet and practise overseas. Normally the General Medical Council, which regulates the profession, gets 20-25 requests a day for certificates of professional status, which make it easier to work abroad. From September 16th-18th it received a staggering 1,644 requests.


Monday, August 3, 2015

UK Health Coverage

From EP Monthly:

"Man in Great Britain mugged, had his bicycle stolen, and had his leg broken in the process. He called emergency services, but was told that his injury 'wasn’t serious enough' to send an ambulance. Three police officers gave him a ride home where he had to book an Uber ride to get him to the hospital. Good thing he had medical 'insurance,' though."

Sunday, October 12, 2014

UK Health Strike

Labor unrest in the UK government-run health system: "Why we’re striking: NHS staff on their decision to walk out".
NHS staff in England will stage a strike on Monday in protest at a third year without a pay rise – their first over pay in more than three decades. More than 450,000 people, from cleaners and porters to ambulance drivers and occupational therapists, will be involved in a four-hour walkout.

Thursday, September 18, 2014

Venezuelan Breast Implant Shortage

The New York Post reports, "Venezuela has chronic shortage of breast implants":
Beauty-obsessed Venezuelans face a scarcity of brand-name breast implants, and women are so desperate that they and their doctors are turning to devices that are the wrong size or made in China, with less rigorous quality standards.

Venezuelans once had easy access to implants approved by the US Food and Drug Administration. But doctors say they are now all but impossible to find because restrictive currency controls have deprived local businesses of the cash to import foreign goods. It may not be the gravest shortfall facing the socialist South American country, but surgeons say the issue cuts to the psyche of the image-conscious Venezuelan woman...
As Dr. Megan Edison quipped online, "The problem with socialism is that eventually you run out of other people's breast implants."

Monday, March 31, 2014

Hsieh Forbes OpEd: What The US Can Learn From the Australian Health Care Debate

My latest OpEd is now up at Forbes: "What The US Can Learn From the Australian Health Care Debate".

Here is the opening:
Is it fair to ask a patient to pay $6 for emergency medical care? Or are patients entitled to free medical care whenever they need it? That's the question Australian government officials are currently grappling with.
As the Australian health care unfolds, there are two lessons for Americans -- one political and one philosophical.

For more details, read the full text of "What The US Can Learn From the Australian Health Care Debate".

(And thanks to WhiteCoat's Call Room for the link to one of the Australian news stories on this topic!)

Monday, January 20, 2014

Canadian Surgeons and Patients End Runs Outside The System

The Calgary Herald reports, "Have scalpel, will travel: Alberta surgeons operate abroad to bypass wait times".

More Canadian doctors are practicing outside the country's borders (e.g., in the Caribbean) to provide patients with faster, better service.

In this case, a Canadian woman chose to have her knee surgery by a Canadian doctor in the Caribbean with only a 2-week wait (rather than a 7 month wait in the government socialized system).

This was after she got a private MRI scan (rather than waiting 8 months for a government-approved MRI scan.)

The article notes it's not merely the "super rich" exercising this option, but also many ordinary people who don't wish to wait.  In the case, the patient was totally reliant on her husband to get around, requiring pain medications that made her woozy.  For her, spending money to receive faster medical care made perfect sense.

This two-tiered system may be the future of American health care in a few years.

Monday, January 13, 2014

Quick Links: Scribes, UK NHS

The New York Times describes how electronic medical records so diminish physician productivity that they have to hire scribes to do their data entry when seeing patients.

From the article:
“Making physicians into secretaries is not a winning proposition,” said Dr. Christine Sinsky, a primary care physician at Medical Associates Clinic and Health Plans, in Dubuque, Iowa, who also researches physician dissatisfaction.

Dr. Sinsky, who was an author of the article in Health Affairs, has visited more than 50 primary care practices over the past five years, in the course of studying ways to stem high rates of physician burnout. She has found that physicians who use scribes are more satisfied with their work and choice of careers.

The inconsistency isn’t lost on health care experts. In most industries, automation leads to increased efficiency, even employee layoffs. In health care, it seems, the computer has created the need for an extra human in the exam room...

Dr. Scott Atlas reminds Americans of the horrible care patients can expect in the UK socialized system (NHS or National Health Service), and how American health care is moving in that directions.

Monday, December 16, 2013

Quick Links: Roy, NHS, Friedman

Avik Roy: "Government Takeover: White House Forces Obamacare Insurers To Cover Unpaid Patients At A Loss"

Telegraph: "Inspectors carrying out first spot checks of family doctors in England find maggots in treatment rooms and queues so long that patients brought in stools to sit on"

Classic Milton Friedman talk from 1978: "Economics of Socialized Medicine"



(I don't agree with Friedman on some issues, but he was very good on this topic.)

Tuesday, July 30, 2013

Quick Links: Docs Avoiding Medicare, Patients Avoiding ObamaCare, Fat In NZ

Wall Street Journal: "More Doctors Steer Clear of Medicare: Some Doctors Opt Out of Program, Frustrated With Payment Rates and Mounting Rules" (7/28/2013).

From the article:
The number of doctors who opted out of Medicare last year, while a small proportion of the nation's health professionals, nearly tripled from three years earlier, according to the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, the government agency that administers the program. Other doctors are limiting the number of Medicare patients they treat even if they don't formally opt out of the system.
NPR: "Canvassers For Health Coverage Find Few Takers In Boca Raton" (7/29/2013)

BBC: "South African chef 'too fat' to live in New Zealand" (7/27/2013)

According to the New Zealand government, "It is important that all migrants have an acceptable standard of health to minimise costs and demands on New Zealand's health services..."

Wednesday, April 24, 2013

$800 Heart Surgery

AFP: "In India, 'no frills' hospitals offer $800 heart surgery"
Using pre-fabricated buildings, stripping out air-conditioning and even training visitors to help with post-operative care, the group believes it can cut the cost of heart surgery to an astonishing 800 dollars.

Monday, March 11, 2013

Age-Based Rationing in Sweden?

Reader J.W. alerted me to this story in the Swedish news about apparent age-based considerations in drug subsidies.

Using Google translate, the article is entitled: "Age weighed in medicine bill" (March 10, 2013).

From the translated version:
Niklas Hedberg, head of the new drugs on the TLV, believes that there is an unfortunate wording, but that the work complies with legislation stipulating that they must weigh each consequence of a drug subsidy. 
-For us it is a very complex issue, the starting point is that society's resources for drugs is limited and we are commissioned to be those that prioritize the allocation between different patient groups. Since the legislation has made clear that we must weigh up different principles, and we will take account of drugs in a society holistically, says Niklas Hedberg. 
Would you expect that retirees actually costs if they survive? 
-What is unfortunate is that you can get the picture that it just is a matter of age, it only concerns pensioners. But I think your question is good and it is also very complex. Should we take into account that a patient can start working or not? It is then output effect comes into play.Consumption effect is always when you extend the life of a treat. 
Are pensioners lives worth less? 
-Everyone's health is valued as much, but the calculation model allows perched on top gives the socio-economic perspective, an added benefit of the treatments that allow the patient group can start working again.
In effect, those who are deemed more productive to society will be given higher priority in the national health system than those who are considered a net drain.

This is a nearly-inevitable outcome when medical care (and the system of payments) is considered a collective good that must be allocated accordingly.

The US isn't at this point yet.  But there are intellectuals and policy writers laying the groundwork for similar rationing here.

(One example is this article, "Principles for allocation of scarce medical interventions", co-authored by former Obama administration health policy advisor Zeke Emanuel, brother to former Obama chief of staff Rahm Emanuel.)

Friday, February 8, 2013

A Look At The Future

Walter Russell Mead: "British Hospital Carnage a Window into US Future".

Related from NYT: "English Hospital Report Cites 'Appalling' Suffering":
The report, which examined conditions at Stafford Hospital in Staffordshire over a 50-month period between 2005 and 2009, cites example after example of horrific treatment: patients left unbathed and lying in their own urine and excrement; patients left so thirsty that they drank water from vases; patients denied medication, pain relief and food by callous and overworked staff members; patients who contracted infections due to filthy conditions; and patients sent home to die after being given the wrong diagnoses. 

“This is the story of the appalling and unnecessary suffering of hundreds of people,” Robert Francis, the lawyer appointed by the government to lead the inquiry, said at a news conference.
Right now, such conditions would be nearly unthinkable here in the US.  For now.

Monday, December 24, 2012

Private Health Care in Sweden

The Guardian reports on, "Private healthcare: the lessons from Sweden" (12/18/2012).

A couple of excerpts:
During an hour-long presentation to the Guardian, St Göran's chief executive, Britta Wallgren, says the 310-bed hospital, serving 430,000 people, outperforms state-owned rivals inside and outside the country.

She says emergency patients see a doctor within half an hour, compared with A&E waits of up to four hours in the NHS. "We took an A&E department that dealt with 35,000 patients a year and now treats 75,000," Wallgren says. "As admissions grow and we have an increasingly elderly population so must our performance improve."

Capio stresses that St Göran has low levels of hospital-acquired infections, and patient surveys record high levels of public satisfaction. It has also produced year-on-year productivity gains – something the state cannot match. Thomas Berglund, Capio's president, says the "profit motive works in healthcare" and companies run on "capitalism, not altruism".
One patient who opposed the private sector used it nonetheless:
"I am one of those Swedes who do not agree that private hospitals should exist," says Christina Rigert, 62, who used to work as an administrator in the hospital but resigned "on principle" when it was privatised a decade ago.

Now back as a patient after gastric band surgery, she says: "The experience was very good. I had no complaints. There's less waiting than other hospitals. I still do not think there should be private hospitals in Sweden but it's happening."
Note that she attacked it, even while benefiting from it.

The system is not perfect.  But it is an encouraging step in the right direction for Sweden.

Now there is an potential reverse argument some might make along the lines of, "Limited government advocates don't think government program X should exist, but they still take advantage of that service while opposing it.  So they're also being hypocritical!" (For instance, roads, schools, libraries, Post Office, Social Security, etc.)

But one key distinction is that these government programs typically use force "crowd out" (either directly or indirectly) the private options, thus leaving ordinary citizens with limited or no choice except to use the government option.

In contrast, introducing private health options into a socialist system adds choice rather than reducing it. And if over time the private choices "crowd out" the government option, I consider that a feature not a bug.


(Read the full text of "Private healthcare: the lessons from Sweden".  H/T: Dr. Matthew Bowdish.)

Thursday, December 6, 2012

Quick Links: ACO Spread, Device Tax, Rate Shock

Bruce Japsen notes: "Obamacare's Accountable Care Approach Reaches 1 in 10 In U.S." (Forbes, 11/26/2012):
The new analysis from consulting firm Oliver Wyman released Monday says the growth of accountable care organizations, or ACOs, has reached up to 25 million to 31 million patients, growing beyond the 2.4 million patients in the government's voluntarily program for seniors  covered by the Medicare health insurance program for the elderly to patients in private and employer-sponsored health plans.
If patients don't like their ACO, there's always this alternative: "Medical tourism booms in Costa Rica".

Reuters: "IRS finalizes new tax for medical devices in healthcare law" (12/5/2012)

Kaiser Health News: "State Insurance Officials Raise Concerns About 'Rate Shock' For Young People" (12/4/2012).